Konferensartikel

The Quest for a Perfect Death. Thoughts on Death and Dying in the Future

Markus Zimmermann-Acklin
Department of Moral Theology and Ethics, University of Fribourg, Switzerland

Ladda ner artikel

Ingår i: Proceedings from the Societas Ethica Annual Conference 2011; The Quest for perfection. The Future of Medicine/Medicine of the future; August 25-28; 2011; Universita della Svizzera Italiana; Lugano; Switzerland

Linköping Electronic Conference Proceedings 74:6, s. 75-83

Visa mer +

Publicerad: 2013-01-28

ISBN:

ISSN: 1650-3686 (tryckt), 1650-3740 (online)

Abstract

From the title of the conference I’d like to call my essay The quest for a perfect death. Thoughts on death and dying in the future. I’ve divided my text into three parts: In the first almost descriptive and hermeneutical part I give some insights into present social developments concerning death and dying in our high income societies. Inspired by the guiding questions in the program of the Conference I sketch two extreme future scenarios in the second part: the assisted suicide scenario and the “palliative care” scenario. As the labeling of the two outlines already reveals I presuppose value judgments; respectively assumptions; about a good and bad death without opening them up to discussion. In the third part I try to outline a desirable future scenario with regard to recent developments. That third part is normative since I draft some moral arguments concerning death and dying in the near future. The central idea of my vision of the future is centered on the assumption that an art of dying (ars moriendi) is identical to an art of living (ars vivendi). Because an over-planned life could end up in a state of self-blockade; we should envision the rediscovering of acceptance of what once was called “fate”.

Nyckelord

Good death; dying well; finitude of life; assisted suicide; palliative care; selfdetermination; ars moriendi; ars vivendi

Referenser

[1] Kübler-Ross; E. On Death and Dying. What the Dying Have to Teach Doctors; Nurses; Clergy; and Their Own Families. New York; Touchstone 1997 (first published 1969).

[1] Kellehear; A. “What the social and behavioural studies says about dying” in Kellehear; A. (Ed.) The study of dying. From autonomy to transformation. Cambridge; Cambridge University Press 2009; 1–26.

[2] Macho; T.; Marek; K. (Hrsg.). Die neue Sichtbarkeit des Todes. München; Wilhelm Fink 2007.

[3] Nassehi; A. "’Worüber man nicht sprechen kann; darüber muss man schweigen.’ Über die Geschwätzigkeit des Todes in unserer Zeit“ in Liessmann; K. P. (Hrsg.) Ruhm; Tod; Unsterblichkeit. Wien; Zsolnay 2004; 118–145.

[4] Gronemeyer; R. Sterben in Deutschland. Wie wir dem Tod wieder einen Platz in unserm Leben einräumen können Frankfurt; S. Fischer 2007.

[5] Schneider; W. „Wandel und Kontinuität von Sterben und Tod in der Moderne. Zur gesellschaftlichen Ordnung des Lebensendes“ in Bauernfeind; I.; Mendl; G.; Schill; K. (Hrsg.). Über das Sterben. Entscheiden und Handeln am Ende des Lebens. München: Zuckschwerdt 2005; 30–54.

[6] Hurst; S.; Mauron; A. “The ethics of palliative care and euthanasia: exploring common values” in Palliative Medicine Vol. 20; 2006; 107–112.

[7] Bilsen; J.; Cohen; J; Deliens; L. “End of life in Europe: an overview of medical practices” in Bulletin mensuel d’informations de l’Institut national d’études démographiques. Populations & Société No. 430; 2007; 1; zitiert nach Mathwig; F. Zwischen Leben und Tod. Die Suizidhilfediskussion in der Schweiz aus theologisch-ethischer Sicht. Zürich TVZ 2010; 63.

[8] van der Heide; A.; Deliens; L.; Faisst; K.; Nilstun; T.; Norup; M.; Paci; E.; van der Wal; G.; van der Maas; P.J. “End-of-life Decision-Making in Six European Countries: Descriptive Study” Lancet Vol. 362; 2003; 345–350.

[9] Nuland; S. B. How We Die. New York; Alfred A. Knopf 1994.

[10] van Lommel; P. Consciousness beyond life. The science of the near-death experience. New York; HarperOne 2010.

[11] Bloch; E. The Principle of hope. Vol. 2. Cambridge; MIT-Press 1986.

[12] Nietzsche; F. Zarathustra. Ein Buch für Alle und Keinen. KSA; Band 4; München; Deutscher Taschenbuch Verlag 1999. For the English translation (Zarathustra. A Book for All and None) see: www.hamilton.net.au/nietzsche/zarathustra/index.html (13.6.2012).

[13] Thomas More; Utopia (first published in 1518). Maryland: Arc Manor 2008.

[14] Williams; B. “The Makropulos case: reflections on the tedium of immortality” in Williams; B.; Problems of the self. Philosophical papers 1956–1972. New York & London; Cambridge University Press 1973; 82–100.

[15] Feinmann; J. “Breaking Down the Barriers to a Good Death” in Lancet Vol. 360; 1846; 2002.

[16] Dresske; S. „Die Herstellung des ‚guten Sterbens’. Arbeit an der Identitätssicherung im Hospiz“ in Saake; I.; Vogd; W. (Hrsg.). Moderne Mythen der Medizin. Studien zur organisierten Krankenbehandlung. Wiesbaden; VS Verlag 2008; 215–235.

[17] Epikur; Briefe; Sprüche; Werkfragmente. Griechisch/Deutsch. Stuttgart; Reclam 2000.

[18] Tausch; A.-M.; Tausch; R. Sanftes Sterben. Was der Tod für das Leben bedeutet. Reinbek; Rowohlt Taschenbuch Verlag 2004.

[19] Seel; M. „Aktive und passive Selbstbestimmung“ in Merkur Vol. 54; 2000; 626–632.

Citeringar i Crossref