Marzia Varutti
Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies, (IHEID), Geneva, Switzerland
Download article
Published in: National museums in a global world. NaMu III; Department of culture studies and oriental languages; University of Oslo; Norway; 19-21 November 2007
Linköping Electronic Conference Proceedings 31:6, p. 69-79
Published: 2008-07-16
ISBN:
ISSN: 1650-3686 (print), 1650-3740 (online)
In this paper; I propose to analyse the way in which the British Museum perceives; interprets and addresses cultural diversity. As a case study; I consider the museum representation of the Chinese ‘Other’. Building on an analysis of the Chinese permanent gallery as well as of the temporary exhibition “The First Emperor: China’s Terracotta Army”; I set to investigate how the Museum portrays China and Chinese culture. What is exhibited and what is omitted? How is the image of China constructed? What forces – political; economic; social or other – contributed to shape it? Through these questions; I aim at pondering how the representation of China in the British Museum articulates with the expectations of its multi-cultural and increasingly globalized public.
The colonial past is often a key factor in the museum representation of other cultures; and as such it has legitimately been at the core of the reflection on museums’ approaches to alterity. However; I want to argue that the analysis should not be confined to colonialist or post-colonialist historical perspectives; but remain open to include contemporary socio-political and economic factors. The British Museum case study suggests that the economy of travel; the evolution of consumer tastes and demands; renewed opportunities for commercial exchange and business enterprise; an important Chinese community in London and the UK; and global scale media events such as the upcoming 2008 Olympic Games (hosted by China); are all factors that affect museums and museum representations; to the extent that they impact on audiences; on their tastes; interests and expectations. It is of crucial importance to acknowledge that museums are becoming increasingly receptive vis-à-vis such patterns of change; all the more if of global scale.
Methodologically; the arguments put forward in this paper rest on an analysis of the museological choices underlying the displays in the Chinese permanent gallery and the temporary exhibition “The First Emperor: China’s Terracotta Army” aimed at disentangling the narrative lines underlying the exhibitions.
Through this analysis I wish to suggest that the museum representation of the Chinese ‘Other’ at the British Museum rests on two different; though complementary; narrative lines. On the one hand; in the permanent gallery; the Museum is carrying on its ‘traditional’ function as a public education institution. On the other; in temporary exhibition; the Museum is responding to the demand for cultural consumption of its increasingly consumption-oriented audiences.
Clunas; Craig 1987. Chinese export art and design; London: Victoria & Albert Museum.
—1997a. Art in China; Oxford: Oxford University Press.
—1997b. ‘Oriental Antiquities/Far Eastern Art’; in Barlow Tani (ed.); Formations of colonial modernity in East Asia; Durham and London: Duke University Press.
1998. ‘China in Britain: the imperial collections’; in Tim Barringer and T. Flynn (eds); Colonialism and the object. Empire; material culture and the museum; London: Routledge; p.41–41.
Duara; Prasenjit 1988. ‘Superscribing Symbols: The Myth of Guandi; Chinese God of War’; The Journal of Asian Studies; Vol. 47; no. 4; pp. 778–795.
Edwards; Elizabeth; Gosden Chris; Phillips; Ruth B. (eds); 2006; Sensible objects. Colonialism; Museums and Material Culture; Oxford: Berg.
Fabian; Johannes 1983. Time and the other: how anthropology makes its object; New York: Columbia University Press.
Fowler; Don D 1987. ‘Uses of the past: Archaeology in the service of the State’; American Antiquity; Vol. 52; no. 2; pp. 230–247.
Giebelhausen; Michaela (ed) 2003. The architecture of the museum; symbolic structures; urban contexts; Manchester: Manchester University Press.
Grasseni; Cristina 2007. “Introduction” in Grasseni (ed.); Skilled visions: between apprenticeship and standards; Oxford: Berghahn.
Kesner; Ladislav 1995. ‘Likeness of No One: (Re)presenting the First Emperor’s Army’; The Art Bulletin; Vol. 77; no. 1; pp. 115–132.
Kirshenblatt-Gimblett; Barbara 2006. ‘Exhibitionary complex’; in Ivan Karp; Corinne A. Kratz; Lynn Szwaja; Tomás Ybarra-Frausto (eds); Museum frictions. Public cultures/Global transformations; Durham and London: Duke University Press.
Ledderose; Lothar 2000. Ten thousand things: module and mass production in Chinese art; Princeton; N.J. : Princeton University Press.
Miller; Daniel 1987. Material culture and mass consumption; Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
Pagani; Catherine 1998. ‘Chinese material cultural and British perceptions of China in the mid- nineteenth century’; in Tim Barringer and Flynn Tom (eds); Colonialism and the object. Empire; material culture and the museum; London: Routledge; p.28–40.
Portal; Jane and Qingbo Duan 2007. The first Emperor. China’s terracotta army; London: British Museum Press.
